Models to gain knowledge about brain diseases
Ivan Nalvarte and his research group study the human brain and neurological diseases. Such studies still require laboratory animals. But there is an ongoing development of new and more human-relevant models based on human cells.
Ivan Nalvarte is a researcher and associate professor at the Department of Biosciences and Nutrition at Karolinska Institutet. He leads a research group of six people, who study the influence of different hormone receptors on brain development and disease. They use both mice and cell models in their research.
They develop so-called organoids based on cultured human cells. These models can provide more relevant knowledge about human biology and disease than laboratory animals do.
Since February 2023 Ivan is a new regular member of the Swedish National Committee for the Protection of Animals used for Scientific Purposes.
Sex hormones and the brain
In his research, Ivan studies how sex hormones play a role in the risk of developing neurological diseases such as depression and Alzheimer's disease. The studies show clear gender differences, as women run a greater risk of being affected. Ivan says:
– One of our major projects involves comparing studies in mice and organoids with data from epidemiological studies with human volunteers. How important are phases in life when levels of sex hormones drop drastically, such as menopause, for the risk of developing Alzheimer's disease later in life?
He also mentions an upcoming project, where they will use computer models to predict risk and identify hormonal biomarkers for mental illness linked to early development, puberty, pregnancy and menopause.
Mice are not humans
Unlike humans, mice do not develop Alzheimer's disease. The nerve cells in mouse Alzheimer's models are not affected in the same way as in humans and have greater resistance to the plaques that form in the disease. And memory disturbances are not as strong in mice as in humans.
All this leads to the fact that a mouse is not really a good model for studying human neurodegenerative diseases, but in the absence of other models it has still been useful with the help of various mutations.
Ivan is clear to emphasize the importance of mice to the knowledge we have actually gained about Alzheimer's disease today. He is also clear about the need for more human-based methods for us to better understand the causes behind the disease.
Speed and quantity
The advantage of organoids is that they are based on human cells and provide a 3D environment that can mimic certain organ architecture. Since they can be derived from patient cells, organoids can be used to model human disease and suggest more personalized treatments. Relative to the use of animals, organoids can be grown quickly and at a relatively low cost. But there are challenges:
– Right now, we struggle to get immune cells – so-called microglial cells – to grow together with neurons in our organoids, says Ivan. Once we have a mature organoid, we induce something similar to Alzheimer's disease pathology in it. We can then study the interaction between nerve and immune cells at a molecular level, which is difficult to do in animals.
Another concern is that the organoids are to some extent produced with the help of stem cells, so-called iPS cells, that to some extent retain their stem cell capacity in the mature organoid. This means that the organoid can regenerate cells that die. That is not how it works in a real brain. Ivan says:
– We must consider that we do not get an organoid with only mature cells; immature cells remain and can influence the pathology. We need additional time to optimize our organoids to mirror neurodegenerative conditions.
Nor can one study cognitive behaviours in an organoid. For example, researchers still need to study memory deficits in living mice. But with the help of organoids, many parts of an experiment can be done without animals, unlike previous research where there was a lack of alternatives.
Protocols and infrastructures
Ivan and his team expect to need another two years to create qualified organoids. They must also produce a simple and clear description in form of a research protocol, which is easy to follow for others who will use the model.
Short delivery times and large-scale production at a relatively low cost provide good conditions for use. But in order to bring about a real change, infrastructure adaptations towards high-throughput must be developed and made available to the individual researcher.
– To be able to grow enough organoids of good quality, one needs for example some form of bioreactor, says Ivan. We have built our own semi-high-throughput bioreactor together with engineers at KTH, but you cannot expect all research groups to do that.
Challenges and possibilities
Ivan mentions other challenges for new methods to gain ground; demands for animal experiments from scientific journals, knowledge of new methods among researchers in general, but also among the ethics committees that evaluate all applications for ethical approval of animal experiments.
He also emphasizes the importance of increased funding to develop, evaluate and validate new methods. This issue must be raised by many different forces, where the National Committee and the 3Rs Center can contribute.
– What we do in the National Committee means a lot for the future. When you talk to young researchers, the interest in new methods and human-based models is huge. For someone to work for a change, a national support and commitment could be crucial.